Master Comparison Matrix · 18 Platforms & Plugins
Website Platform, Builder & Overlay WCAG 2.2 AA Scorecard
Side-by-side comparison of default DOM cleanliness, keyboard focus operability, overlay dependency, and top merchant regression traps. Click any software name to read the full teardown and HTML remediation code.
Showing all 18 tested platforms and plugins.
| Platform / Plugin | Category | WCAG 2.2 Score | Keyboard Focus | Overlay Script? | Primary Watchout & Remediation Focus |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ADA Site Review Reference HTML | Website Builder / E-Commerce | 100/100Verified Clean HTML | Pass | No | Open reference standard: semantic HTML, >= 4.5:1 tokens, 0 axe violations |
| WP Accessibility (Joe Dolson) | WordPress Ecosystem | 86/100Conditional Pass | Pass | No | Fixes skip links, lang & focus rings; theme palette contrast still yours |
| Shopify (Unmodified Dawn + Checkout) | Website Builder / E-Commerce | 84/100Conditional Pass | Pass | No | Clean core; third-party spin-to-win & swatch apps drop scores to ~77 |
| Astra Theme (WordPress Block) | WordPress Ecosystem | 82/100Conditional Pass | Pass | No | Strong skip link & header semantics; starter templates need contrast checks |
| BentoBox (CMS HTML Menus) | Restaurant & POS | 80/100Conditional Pass | Pass | No | Clean when dishes live in CMS; breaks when owners upload PDF catering flyers |
| Wix Studio | Website Builder / E-Commerce | 78/100Needs Code Fixes | Pass | No | Good built-in Accessibility Wizard; watch heavy wrapper DOM & pastel buttons |
| SimplePractice (Client Portal) | Booking & Clinic | 78/100Needs Code Fixes | Pass | No | Portal booking is solid; clinic marketing sites fail on scanned PDF intake forms |
| Squarespace 7.1 (Fluid Engine) | Website Builder / E-Commerce | 76/100Needs Code Fixes | Partial | No | Freeform CSS grid dragging can desync visual layout from keyboard Tab order |
| Toast Online Ordering | Restaurant & POS | 74/100Needs Code Fixes | Partial | No | Core cart works; dense modifier modals & marketing-site PDF menus trigger claims |
| ChowNow | Restaurant & POS | 73/100Needs Code Fixes | Partial | No | Verify custom embed trigger button focus outlines and allergen text labels |
| Elementor (WordPress) | WordPress Ecosystem | 70/100Needs Code Fixes | Partial | No | Popup Builder modals, empty icon links, and skipped heading levels |
| OpenTable Embedded Widget | Booking & Clinic | 68/100Needs Code Fixes | Partial | No | Untitled wrapper iframes & custom theme combobox bars; direct link is safer |
| Mindbody Embedded Widgets | Booking & Clinic | 66/100Needs Code Fixes | Fail | No | Legacy schedule tables crowd 320px phones and use small filter chips |
| Popmenu | Restaurant & POS | 64/100Needs Code Fixes | Fail | No | Auto-opening VIP modals, dish gallery alt gaps, and dense tab stops |
| Divi (WordPress) | WordPress Ecosystem | 62/100Needs Code Fixes | Fail | No | Legacy non-button accordion triggers and suppressed focus outlines |
| AudioEye (Toolbar-Only Tier) | Overlay Widget | 49/100High Litigation Risk | Fail | Yes (Runtime JS) | Toolbar alone leaves source templates & PDFs unfixed; enterprise human tier costs extra |
| UserWay / EqualWeb (Widget Tier) | Overlay Widget | 47/100High Litigation Risk | Fail | Yes (Runtime JS) | Runtime toolbar cannot fix server HTML, form labels, or untagged PDFs |
| accessiBe (accessWidget) | Overlay Widget | 46/100High Litigation Risk | Fail | Yes (Runtime JS) | 2025 $1M FTC order over compliance claims; 22.6%-28% of sued sites had overlays |
Read our Playwright + Deque axe-core scoring formula or nominate a platform or WordPress plugin missing from this matrix.