ADA Site Review Open Benchmark & Award Badge
The Verified Clean HTML Standard (95-100/100): How Our Open Playwright + axe-core Scorecard & Badge Work
Verdict
The ADA Site Review scorecard evaluates rendered web pages in Headless Chromium using open-source Deque axe-core across WCAG 2.0, 2.1, and 2.2 Level A & AA rules, paired with a keyboard focus-ring probe, 320px reflow check, and overlay script detector. Platforms, themes, and agency sites scoring 95 to 100/100 with zero critical, serious, or moderate violations, clean keyboard focus, and zero overlay scripts qualify for our free embeddable Verified Clean HTML SVG badge.
- Critical / serious
- 0 / 0
- Moderate / minor
- 0 / 0
- Keyboard
- Pass
- Overlay script
- None
Key findings
- Open Deduction Formula: Starts at 100, deducting 14 points per critical violation, 9 per serious, 5 per moderate, 2 per minor, up to 12 for keyboard focus/trap failures, and 6 for unmediated PDF-only menus.
- Mandatory Honesty Floor: Deque axe-core automatically catches ~57% of WCAG 2.0-2.2 issues with zero false positives (QAble / Deque). Our badge certifies clean semantic HTML and keyboard operability, never legal immunity.
- Zero Paid Placements: Vendors cannot buy a higher score or pay to suppress an audit finding. Re-tests after genuine HTML fixes are free.
- Zero-Script SVG Badge: The Verified Clean HTML badge is a lightweight, accessible static SVG + anchor snippet with explicit width, height, and alt text.
Breakdown
| Score Tier | Range | Qualification Requirements | Badge Eligible? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Verified Clean HTML | 95 - 100 | 0 Critical/Serious/Moderate axe violations + Keyboard Pass + 320px Reflow + No Overlay | Yes (Free SVG Badge) |
| Conditional Pass | 80 - 94 | 0 Critical violations; minor theme contrast or landmark polish needed | After re-test >= 95 |
| Needs Code Fixes | 60 - 79 | Repeatable ARIA, heading, iframe, or contrast defects requiring template edits | No |
| High Litigation Risk | Below 60 | Multiple Critical/Serious blockers, keyboard traps, PDF-only menus, or overlay masking | No |
Failing markup and the fix
<div class="nav"><div onclick="go('/')">Home</div></div>
<div class="hero-title">Welcome</div>
<script src="https://overlay-vendor.example/patch.js"></script><a href="https://adasitereview.com/badges/" rel="noopener">
<img
src="https://adasitereview.com/badges/verified-clean-html.svg"
alt="Verified Clean HTML (WCAG 2.2 AA) - ADA Site Review"
width="220"
height="56"
loading="lazy"
>
</a>Why reward clean native HTML with an open editorial badge?
For years, the only visible "accessibility badges" on small-business websites were commercial overlay icons that signaled runtime patching rather than clean engineering. Web designers, theme authors, and craft-focused agencies who take the time to write genuine semantic HTML, high-contrast tokens, and accessible forms deserve a credible way to show their work.
What happens if a badged template or agency site regresses later?
Every Verified Clean HTML award records the git or scan date verified. If a subsequent re-test discovers new critical or serious WCAG 2.2 AA violations, we notify the maintainer with a 30-day remediation window before moving the listing to Conditional Pass or Needs Code Fixes.
Questions
Does ADA Site Review charge a licensing fee to display the Verified Clean HTML badge?
Never. Qualifying platforms, open-source plugins, and digital agencies scoring 95-100/100 may embed the static SVG badge free of charge as long as it links to our public verification and methodology page.
Has a vendor release fixed something above? Request a free re-test or read how we test.