# ADA Site Review

> ADA Site Review (https://adasitereview.com) is a standalone WCAG 2.2 Level AA website accessibility observatory publishing empirical Headless Chromium + Deque axe-core teardowns of SMB website platforms, hospitality ordering and booking widgets, accessibility overlay scripts, WordPress page builders, and aggregate industry cohort studies.

## Canonical Scope & Testing Standard
- Primary engine: Headless Chromium (`playwright-core`) + open-source Deque `axe-core` evaluating WCAG 2.0, 2.1, and 2.2 Level A & AA rules (`wcag2a`, `wcag2aa`, `wcag21a`, `wcag21aa`, `wcag22aa`), paired with keyboard focus probes, 320px reflow checks, and overlay script detection.
- Honesty standard: Automated `axe-core` testing reliably detects ~57% of WCAG 2.0-2.2 issues with zero false positives and pairs with manual keyboard and screen-reader checks. Published teardowns are technical and educational research, never legal advice.
- Cohort ethics: Software platforms, plugins, and commercial widgets are reviewed by name; digital agency and industry studies report aggregate patterns without naming-and-shaming individual small businesses.
- Verified Clean HTML Badge (`95-100/100`): Awarded free of charge to platforms, themes, and agency sites passing with zero Critical, Serious, or Moderate `axe-core` violations, clean keyboard focus, 320px reflow, and zero overlay scripts.

## Primary-Sourced Industry Benchmarks (Verified 2026-11-18)
- **3,117 (2025 Federal Website Filings)**: Up 27% year over year; Florida ranked #2 nationally with 961 federal cases. Source: Accessibility.build & Seyfarth Shaw.
- **853 (Q3 2026 Hospitality Lawsuits)**: Restaurants, food, and beverage led single-quarter filings over PDF menus and booking flows. Source: EcomBack Q3 2026 Report.
- **$1M (FTC Overlay Consent Order)**: 2025 FTC final order against accessiBe; 22.6% to 28% of sued sites carried an overlay widget. Source: FTC.gov, Samuel Law & UsableNet.
- **95.9% (Homepages Failing WCAG 2)**: Averaging 56.1 detectable errors per page across the WebAIM Million sample. Source: WebAIM Million.

## 18-Platform & Plugin Master Scorecard (https://adasitereview.com/scorecards/)
- **ADA Site Review Reference HTML** (Website Builder / E-Commerce): **100/100** (Verified Clean HTML, Keyboard: Pass, Overlay: No). Watchout: Open reference standard: semantic HTML, >= 4.5:1 tokens, 0 axe violations. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/verified-clean-html-award-standard/
- **WP Accessibility (Joe Dolson)** (WordPress Ecosystem): **86/100** (Conditional Pass, Keyboard: Pass, Overlay: No). Watchout: Fixes skip links, lang & focus rings; theme palette contrast still yours. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/wp-accessibility-plugin-honest-review/
- **Shopify (Unmodified Dawn + Checkout)** (Website Builder / E-Commerce): **84/100** (Conditional Pass, Keyboard: Pass, Overlay: No). Watchout: Clean core; third-party spin-to-win & swatch apps drop scores to ~77. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/shopify-dawn-checkout-ada-compliance-audit/
- **Astra Theme (WordPress Block)** (WordPress Ecosystem): **82/100** (Conditional Pass, Keyboard: Pass, Overlay: No). Watchout: Strong skip link & header semantics; starter templates need contrast checks. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/elementor-divi-astra-wordpress-wcag-audit/
- **BentoBox (CMS HTML Menus)** (Restaurant & POS): **80/100** (Conditional Pass, Keyboard: Pass, Overlay: No). Watchout: Clean when dishes live in CMS; breaks when owners upload PDF catering flyers. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/toast-bentobox-popmenu-chownow-menu-audit/
- **Wix Studio** (Website Builder / E-Commerce): **78/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Pass, Overlay: No). Watchout: Good built-in Accessibility Wizard; watch heavy wrapper DOM & pastel buttons. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/squarespace-vs-wix-accessibility-scorecard/
- **SimplePractice (Client Portal)** (Booking & Clinic): **78/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Pass, Overlay: No). Watchout: Portal booking is solid; clinic marketing sites fail on scanned PDF intake forms. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/mindbody-simplepractice-clinic-booking-audit/
- **Squarespace 7.1 (Fluid Engine)** (Website Builder / E-Commerce): **76/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Partial, Overlay: No). Watchout: Freeform CSS grid dragging can desync visual layout from keyboard Tab order. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/squarespace-vs-wix-accessibility-scorecard/
- **Toast Online Ordering** (Restaurant & POS): **74/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Partial, Overlay: No). Watchout: Core cart works; dense modifier modals & marketing-site PDF menus trigger claims. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/toast-bentobox-popmenu-chownow-menu-audit/
- **ChowNow** (Restaurant & POS): **73/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Partial, Overlay: No). Watchout: Verify custom embed trigger button focus outlines and allergen text labels. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/toast-bentobox-popmenu-chownow-menu-audit/
- **Elementor (WordPress)** (WordPress Ecosystem): **70/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Partial, Overlay: No). Watchout: Popup Builder modals, empty icon links, and skipped heading levels. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/elementor-divi-astra-wordpress-wcag-audit/
- **OpenTable Embedded Widget** (Booking & Clinic): **68/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Partial, Overlay: No). Watchout: Untitled wrapper iframes & custom theme combobox bars; direct link is safer. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/opentable-reservation-widget-wcag-teardown/
- **Mindbody Embedded Widgets** (Booking & Clinic): **66/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Fail, Overlay: No). Watchout: Legacy schedule tables crowd 320px phones and use small filter chips. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/mindbody-simplepractice-clinic-booking-audit/
- **Popmenu** (Restaurant & POS): **64/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Fail, Overlay: No). Watchout: Auto-opening VIP modals, dish gallery alt gaps, and dense tab stops. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/toast-bentobox-popmenu-chownow-menu-audit/
- **Divi (WordPress)** (WordPress Ecosystem): **62/100** (Needs Code Fixes, Keyboard: Fail, Overlay: No). Watchout: Legacy non-button accordion triggers and suppressed focus outlines. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/elementor-divi-astra-wordpress-wcag-audit/
- **AudioEye (Toolbar-Only Tier)** (Overlay Widget): **49/100** (High Litigation Risk, Keyboard: Fail, Overlay: Yes). Watchout: Toolbar alone leaves source templates & PDFs unfixed; enterprise human tier costs extra. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/userway-audioeye-equalweb-overlay-comparison/
- **UserWay / EqualWeb (Widget Tier)** (Overlay Widget): **47/100** (High Litigation Risk, Keyboard: Fail, Overlay: Yes). Watchout: Runtime toolbar cannot fix server HTML, form labels, or untagged PDFs. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/userway-audioeye-equalweb-overlay-comparison/
- **accessiBe (accessWidget)** (Overlay Widget): **46/100** (High Litigation Risk, Keyboard: Fail, Overlay: Yes). Watchout: 2025 $1M FTC order over compliance claims; 22.6%-28% of sued sites had overlays. Full teardown: https://adasitereview.com/reviews/accessibe-overlay-axe-core-teardown/

## Published Teardowns & Cohort Reports (12 Total)

### SMB, Restaurant & Clinic Platforms (https://adasitereview.com/pillars/platforms/)
- [Toast, BentoBox, Popmenu & ChowNow Menu Teardown: Which Restaurant Platform Ships Clean HTML?](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/toast-bentobox-popmenu-chownow-menu-audit/) (Score: 31/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): Restaurants, food, and beverage businesses drew 853 website accessibility lawsuits in Q3 2026 (EcomBack), with Florida ranking #2 nationally at 961 federal website filings in 2025. Across Toast, BentoBox, Popmenu, and ChowNow, core dish lists have improved, yet restaurant owners routinely fail WCAG 2.2 Level AA when uploading untagged catering PDFs, leaving modifier groups unlabeled, or overriding button colors below 4.5:1.
- [Squarespace 7.1 vs. Wix Studio Accessibility Scorecard: Default Templates Tested With axe-core](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/squarespace-vs-wix-accessibility-scorecard/) (Score: 77/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): Both Squarespace 7.1 and Wix Studio include built-in skip links and improved ARIA defaults compared with five years ago, earning a 77/100 baseline in our SMB template specimen audit. Wix Studio leads on built-in accessibility wizard checks and landmark controls, while Squarespace 7.1 produces cleaner HTML weight; both platforms fail WCAG 2.2 AA when users drag blocks out of reading order or keep low-contrast starter palettes.
- [Is the OpenTable Reservation Widget ADA Compliant? WCAG 2.2 Keyboard & Iframe Teardown](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/opentable-reservation-widget-wcag-teardown/) (Score: 68/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): OpenTable hosted reservation pages have matured significantly in ARIA labeling, yet restaurant websites embedding OpenTable via custom iframes or wrapper modals frequently introduce WCAG 2.4.1 and 4.1.2 violations. Our specimen benchmark scored 68/100 due to untitled wrapper iframes, broken ARIA combobox wrappers on custom date/time bars, and low-contrast unavailable time-slot pills.
- [Is Shopify ADA Compliant Out of the Box? Dawn Theme, Cart Drawer & Checkout WCAG 2.2 Audit](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/shopify-dawn-checkout-ada-compliance-audit/) (Score: 77/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): Unmodified Shopify Dawn and Shopify hosted Checkout are among the most accessible mainstream commerce foundations available, featuring proper form labels, live-region cart announcements, and keyboard drawer management. However, live Shopify stores averaged 77/100 in our app-augmented storefront specimen because merchants install third-party spin-to-win popups, unlabeled swatch apps, and low-contrast urgency badges.
- [Mindbody & SimplePractice Booking Widgets Tested: WCAG 2.2 Clinic & Studio Teardown](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/mindbody-simplepractice-clinic-booking-audit/) (Score: 73/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): Healthcare, dental, therapy, and wellness practices operate under heightened accessibility scrutiny under ADA Title III and federal HHS Section 504 digital rules referencing WCAG 2.1/2.2 Level AA. In our clinic booking specimen audit (73/100), SimplePractice hosted client portals outperformed legacy Mindbody healcode widgets, while clinic websites themselves repeatedly failed on scanned PDF intake packets and placeholder-only callback forms.

### Overlays & WordPress Plugins (https://adasitereview.com/pillars/overlays-and-plugins/)
- [accessiBe Tested With Headless Chromium & axe-core: What Changes in the DOM (and the $1M FTC Order)](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/accessibe-overlay-axe-core-teardown/) (Score: 46/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): In 2025, the Federal Trade Commission approved a final order requiring accessiBe to pay $1 million over unsubstantiated claims that its AI overlay (accessWidget) could make any website WCAG compliant, and for presenting connected third-party reviews as impartial user opinions. In our empirical Chromium + Deque axe-core specimen test (46/100), loading a runtime overlay leaves broken source HTML, unlabeled inputs, keyboard-trapping divs, and untagged PDF menus exposed.
- [Elementor vs. Divi vs. Astra: WordPress Page Builder DOM & Keyboard Accessibility Scorecard](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/elementor-divi-astra-wordpress-wcag-audit/) (Score: 70/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): WordPress powers over 40% of the web, and page-builder defaults determine whether millions of local business sites pass or fail WCAG 2.2 Level AA. Across our WordPress builder specimen tests (70/100 composite), Astra ships the cleanest semantic header and skip-link foundation, Elementor has improved ARIA attributes on newer Flexbox/Grid widgets while still risking popup focus traps, and legacy Divi modules require the heaviest manual remediation for keyboard navigation.
- [UserWay, AudioEye & EqualWeb Compared: Do Floating Toolbars Fix Underlying WCAG 2.2 Code?](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/userway-audioeye-equalweb-overlay-comparison/) (Score: 47/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): UserWay, AudioEye, and EqualWeb each market tiered accessibility packages ranging from self-serve JavaScript toolbars ($490+ per year) to enterprise managed services. In our multi-widget DOM benchmark (47/100 for script-only deployment), standalone toolbar widgets from any vendor share the same architectural ceiling: client-side UI panels cannot rewrite broken CMS templates, remediate untagged PDFs, or replace real source-code engineering.
- [WP Accessibility Plugin Review: What Joe Dolson's Free WordPress Plugin Fixes (and What Still Needs Theme Code)](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/wp-accessibility-plugin-honest-review/) (Score: 86/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): WP Accessibility (maintained by WordPress Core Accessibility team contributor Joe Dolson) is the rare WordPress accessibility plugin we recommend with confidence, earning an 86/100 baseline when paired with a typical theme. Because it fixes real HTML defects (adding skip links, html lang attributes, focus outlines, and removing target="_blank" traps) without claiming instant legal immunity, it serves as an honest companion to theme-level CSS and content remediation.

### Cohort Studies & Clean HTML Standard (https://adasitereview.com/pillars/cohort-reports/)
- [Who Watches the Watchmen? We Tested 50 Web Design Agency Sites for WCAG 2.2 Level AA](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/digital-agency-websites-wcag-cohort-report/) (Score: 56/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): Small businesses trust web design agencies to deliver ADA-compliant websites, yet WebAIM Million data shows 95.9% of top homepages fail automated WCAG checks (averaging 56.1 errors per page). In our aggregate cohort study of 50 web design and creative agency showcase sites (representative specimen score: 56/100; zero individual firms named-and-shamed), 84% failed WCAG 1.4.3 color contrast, 62% contained unlabeled portfolio or social icon links, and 44% shipped autoplay background reels without pause controls or reduced-motion guards.
- [Practice What You Preach: Auditing Accessibility Vendors & ADA Info Hubs Against WCAG 2.2 AA](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/accessibility-vendor-and-info-hub-cohort-study/) (Score: 86/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): Even organizations dedicated to digital accessibility suffer regressions when marketing teams paste third-party scripts onto otherwise clean sites. Across our 30-site accessibility vendor and compliance hub cohort (representative specimen score: 86/100), core product documentation generally passed WCAG 2.2 AA, while 37% of tested marketing landing pages failed on third-party cookie consent banners, unlabeled "Work Email" newsletter bars, or low-contrast legal footnotes.
- [The Verified Clean HTML Standard (95-100/100): How Our Open Playwright + axe-core Scorecard & Badge Work](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/verified-clean-html-award-standard/) (Score: 100/100 · Updated 2026-11-18): The ADA Site Review scorecard evaluates rendered web pages in Headless Chromium using open-source Deque axe-core across WCAG 2.0, 2.1, and 2.2 Level A & AA rules, paired with a keyboard focus-ring probe, 320px reflow check, and overlay script detector. Platforms, themes, and agency sites scoring 95 to 100/100 with zero critical, serious, or moderate violations, clean keyboard focus, and zero overlay scripts qualify for our free embeddable Verified Clean HTML SVG badge.

## Core Observatory Hubs & Machine Endpoints
- [All Teardowns & Scorecards](https://adasitereview.com/reviews/)
- [18-Platform Master Comparison Table](https://adasitereview.com/scorecards/)
- [Verified Clean HTML (95-100/100) SVG Badge & Embed Code](https://adasitereview.com/badges/)
- [Open Testing Methodology & Scoring Formula](https://adasitereview.com/methodology/)
- [Submit a Platform, Plugin, or Site for Review](https://adasitereview.com/submit/)
- [Editorial Corrections & Inquiries Form](https://adasitereview.com/contact/)
- [Editorial Standards & Disclosure Policy](https://adasitereview.com/disclosure/)
- XML Sitemap: https://adasitereview.com/sitemap.xml
- RSS 2.0 Feed: https://adasitereview.com/rss.xml
- Build Version Identity: https://adasitereview.com/version.json
